Right now playing the guitar has very little meaning to me. When I pulled it out to play though, my kids swarmed and started strumming it. I grew up without music in my house and I've often envied those that had music and singing in their homes. Not in the forced piano practice way but in the impromptu let's join together around this lovely sound way. I think if I were to get there with my practice and with the occupation, yes it would hold deep meaning for me. But right now, if Reker and Wong's proposition holds true, then I'm at the side that's yielding more meaning from societal expectations.
I set myself up to practice my occupation for one hour yesterday. This took calculative thinking. I got everything out, including a timer and the book. But as I mentioned above my kids essentially attacked me and the guitar. My initial response was to tell them to get away from me so I could do my **** work. But as I paused and thought for a moment, I was reminded that part of the reason I want to learn to play was for them. That turning them away would actually inhibit the meaning I hope to derive from the activity. And that their curiosity and exposure to music and sound is something I want to cultivate. So I let them strum away for a few minutes, which eventually they got bored of anyway. I think this might be the difference between calculative and meditative thinking? The calculative is sticking to the plan and the meditative is looking at the larger picture of the meaning of the action. Could the difference between calculative and meditative thinking be the difference of a pause and reflection of the greater purpose?
I expect the proportion of calculative and meditative thinking to change as (if) I become more proficient with the instrument; more calculative now thinking about how to do the occupation and more meditative later as the process becomes streamlined and my mind can move elsewhere.
Here's a video of Camas... She wasn't as rough on the guitar as Henry.
Let me know if the video works for you... I can't see it on my Mac or iPhone but I'm wondering if it works for those on PC. Thanks!
Liz-
ReplyDeleteI absolutely loved reading your blog! It was very personable and relatable in that I think everyone enjoys music and it's something I feel that most people want to be able to partake in at some point or another in their life. I really enjoyed your take on calculative vs. meditative thinking as well. How one is "sticking to the plan" and the other is "looking at a larger picture of meaning." Even though I think we are naturally more calculative thinkers at first, I do think your meditative thinking is fairly strong within your definition of the two, having already strayed away from a state of planning and kind of just going with the flow for a bit! What do you think?
Hey Lacey, I responded to this last Monday (I thought) though it looks like I had a technical error and it didn't show up? Ugh. Anyways, glad I checked now. I'm not sure we as a species are innately calculative thinkers. I think society has encouraged that in our culture so Americans are but other cultures such as indigenous tribes in the Amazon that haven't been affected by us for example see things in more terms of how things are interconnected and flow rather and have very rudimentary systems for calculative thinking like counting (like 3 words/symbols - 1, 2 and more than two).
Delete